emma_in_dream: (Default)
I want to shout out to Frederick Enoch, a very perceptive reader, who in 1846 bought a copy of the collected poems of the Brontes (published as Acton, Currer and Ellis Bell).


He was one of two – count them, two – people to buy copies of the book that year. Rather embarrassing for the authors, but their readership made up in quality for what it lacked in quantity. Mr Enoch wrote to them, praising the poems and asking for their autographs. He got what turned out to be the only document in the world with the ‘signatures’ of the three Bell brothers on it.


After the publication of *Jane Eyre*, the poetry sold like hot cakes, but Mr Enoch was ahead of his time.
emma_in_dream: (Default)
As it turned out, I lost heart at the thought of rereading *Wuthering Heights*.  It’s such a jumbled mess of over the top emotions, psychic doubling and despair.  Instead, I reread *The Tenant of Wildfeld Hall* which offers a lovely antidote to the craziness of *Wuthering Heights*.

Emily Bronte


I do want to make some comments. *Wuthering Heights* is a ghost story of a peculiarly disturbing kind. Take this passage, where the narrator is lying in his bed, especially the bit where he tries to cut the ghost's wrists, still not sure if it is not actually a real person.

ExpandRead more... )



Anne Bronte


Basically I just want to say that Anne’s heroes are temperate and sane. At least in comparison with Emily and Charlotte’s. Charlotte is all – crazy, pseudo-incestuous relationship with a drunken, brooding bigamist! Woo!  Emily is all – crazy, folie a deux intensity relationship with a drunken, violent brother figure! Woo! Whereas Anne is – hey, men have absolute rights over the bodies and property of their wives so maybe you should choose someone with at least a hint of a conscience.  Less of the woo!, more of the hmmmm.
emma_in_dream: (Bronte)
I read *The Brontes: Selected Poems*, edited by Juliet R.V. Barker (1985). I was given it as a teen and I still really appreciate the work in it, especially Emily Bronte's. (In some ways I think her over the top romanticism works best in the form of poetry rather than the novel).

For the benefit of those who have not had time to find the poetical works of the Brontes, here are some examples:


Charlotte Bronte likes the big, over the top declarations of painful love... Not surprising.

ExpandRead more... )

Poor old Branwell Bronte wrote works which showed off his erudition in the form of classical allusions and which have dated terribly. See if you can read this without snoring...

ExpandRead more... )

Emily Bronte is my favourite. I would probably find her works too over the top if I had come to them as an adult, but I first read them in adolescence so they seem moving to me.

ExpandRead more... )

And this one which came from her imaginary world which she shared with Anne.

ExpandRead more... )

Anne Bronte wrote on a much quieter but still fine scale.

ExpandRead more... )

Some questions to aid discussion.

* What was with the obsession with death? A result of their upbringing or a general nineteenth-century preoccupation? Or a general poetic obssession?

* Does the use of rhyme lead you through the poetry?

* Compare and contrast the siblings.

Our first read of 2011!
emma_in_dream: (Default)
29 January - Poetry of the Brontes.

Choose as much or as little of their work as you like.

Profile

emma_in_dream: (Default)
emma_in_dream

December 2020

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
1314 1516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

Expand All Cut TagsCollapse All Cut Tags
Page generated Jul. 7th, 2025 11:46 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios